ABSTRACTS OF RESEARCH PAPERS,
CASES
AND PRESENTATIONS
WACRA 2000
at The Central European University
BUDAPEST, HUNGARY
July 2-5, 2000
Session 1
WACRA® EXECUTIVE BOARD AND
ADVISORY BOARD MEETING
(Arcotel, Vienna, Austria)
Session 2
CASE WRITERS COLLOQUIUM
James W. Camerius
N. Michigan University
MARQUETTE, MICHIGAN, U.S.A.
For the tenth year WACRA offers workshops specially designed to assist you in learning how to write cases and/or improve your cases. Even if you do not submit a case you are welcome to participate and gain valuable insight into the case research-writing-publishing process.
New Casewriters Workshop: A panel of experienced case researchers will discuss how to research, write and improve cases. Among the topics to be covered will be objectives, various types of case research, information sources, the writing process, and the use and development of effective teaching notes. Integral to this process will be the discussion by panel members of several presented cases and teaching notes. These cases, still in the development state, will demonstrate the case editing and improvement process. Experienced case-writers are also welcome.
The Tenth Annual Casewriters Colloquium:
Both novice and experienced case writers can benefit from the colloquium.
Case presenters, panelists from the workshop, and all other participants
are organized into roundtables for (free-form) discussion of various cases
presented at each table. Following are the cases to be discussed:
FIGHTING AGAINST THE CLOCK
Jane Jackson
The Chinese University of Hong
Kong
HONG KONG SAR, CHINA
Abstract
In 1998 the Enhanced Native English
Teacher (NET) Scheme was initiated in Hong Kong as one solution to the
falling standard of English among schoolchildren. The overall aim is to
place one native-speaker of English in each secondary school in the territory.
This case describes the situation of Mary Martin, a NET from Australia
who is teaching conversation skills in a secondary school in Hong Kong.
In a large Form 4 (Grade 10) class, she has been trying groupwork with
little success. This case is based on interviews with the teacher and observation
of her Form 4 class. Names have been changed to ensure anonymity.
IT TRANSFORMATION AT GRANADA BUSINESS SCHOOL CASE-A
C.P. Rao
Kuwait University
SAFAT, KUWAIT
Abstract
Granada Business School is one of the leading business schools in a country in the Middle East. Although the Granada Business was in existence since mid 1960's, until 1996 it was known as College of Commerce with all the business administration disciplines combined in one department. In 1996 a new dean was appointed who initiated a strategic plan to bring the School to contemporary international standards in terms of updating the curriculum, faculty skills, imparting technology and international orientations to the School's programs. One of the important components of this upgrading program is to transform the IT environment and orientation of the School from a haphazard approach to a more systematic and effective approach comparable to contemporary standards at business schools world over.
To achieve the IT development objectives
at the School, the Dean appointed Dr. Ahmad to develop and implement an
IT development plan. As a first step to bring about the desired IT transformation
at the School, Dr. Ahmad decided to conduct a comprehensive IT audit at
the School so as to review the current situation of the IT environment
prior to 1996. After a thorough investigation early in 1996, the following
report was submitted to Dr. Ahmad to the Dean indicating what needs to
be done to transform the IT environment at the Granada Business School.
IMPERIAL CONNECTORS
Louis Gingerella
Rensselaer Polytechnic Institute
at Hartford
HARTFORD, CONNECTICUT, U.S.A.
Abstract
This case starts with an air of a
merger-induced tension between differing levels of management. Readers
are told how various competing factions have come together under one corporate
umbrella and are then exposed to the sublet maneuverings by some of the
players as they struggle to survive. Part B of the case, however, introduces
an entirely different set of issues for the main character to deal with,
which, given the aforementioned circumstances, he must deal with alone.
STUART & SONS LIMITED: A CASE STUDY
Gerry Mortimer
Dublin Institute of Technology
DUBLIN, IRELAND
Abstract
In August 1995 the crystal manufacturing
firm of Stuart and Sons was purchased by Waterford Wedgwood plc. The company,
which had been family owned since its inception, had not been profitable
for some years. After the takeover, the initial focus was on operational
issues. These took longer to resolve than had been anticipated. However
by early 1998, Stuart and Sons had returned to modest levels of profit
and the balance of focus by the new management began to move towards greater
concentration on the marketplace and a market that could certainly be described
as challenging.
WATERFORD CRYSTAL: THE CHAIRMAN'S CHALLENGE
Gerry Mortimer
Dublin Institute of Technology
DUBLIN, IRELAND
Abstract
The case study is set in mid 1995
when the incoming Chief Executive of Waterford Crystal has committed himself
to taking up what subsequently became known as "The Chairman's Challenge".
The challenge was to double the turnover and profit of Waterford Crystal
within 5 years. In 1995 turnover stood at IRE 117 million and profit at
IRE 15.5 million. Recovery was complete from a very difficult period in
the company's history and the focus was now strongly on growth.
LABORERS LOCAL 829 HEALTH AND WELFARE PLAN HEALTH FUND AND SICK-LEAVE FUND LIABILITY CONSIDERATIONS
Thomas J. Hogan and Peter J. Westort
University of Massachusetts Boston
BOSTON, MASSACHUSETTS, U.S.A.
Abstract
Laborers Local 829 serves as a multi-employer
health care provider for union construction members. The case, based on
discussions with accounting practitioners focuses on accounting situations
which might be faced on an audit engagement. The issues involved include:
testing for unrecorded liabilities, using analytical review to estimate
the accumulated benefit obligation, and report considerations. The case
is realistic in terms of the issues involved and the complexity of the
data presented.
LABORERS LOCAL 829
HEALTH AND WELFARE PLAN ASSET CONCERNS
Thomas J. Hogan, James Bierstaker,
and William Seltz
University of Massachusetts Boston
BOSTON, MASSACHUSETTS, U.S.A.
Abstract
Laborers Local 829 serves as a multi-employer
health care provider for union construction members. The case focuses on
accounting situations involving investments and receivables which might
be faced on an audit engagement. Data for the case was gathered using research
in the field, in conjunction with accounting practitioners.
PLUM VALLEY HOSPITAL: A CRITICAL GOVERNANCE MATTER
Donald Grunewald
Iona College
NEW ROCHELLE, NEW YORK, U.S.A.
Philip Baron
Florida Atlantic University
BOCA RATON, FLORIDA, U.S.A.
Abstract
This case involves the quandary of
a businessman named Arthur Eldredge. A member of the Board of Trustees
of Plum Valley Hospital, he is uneasy about apparent conflicts of interest
among many board members. Further, Mr. Eldredge is unsure if he can fulfill
his responsibilities to the Board. As a trustee of the hospital, he thinks
he should do something about these issues, and he is uncertain about what
action to take.
MOLDING TRANSACTIONAL DATA INTO DECISION MAKING INFORMATION IN THE MEDICAL INDUSTRY: THE CASE OF LABERMAN GENERAL HOSPITAL
Lael Dicksinson
Rensselaer Polytechnic Institute
TROY, NEW YORK, U.S.A.
Abstract
The Chief Executive Officer (CEO) of Laberman General Hospital, Lydia Sherman, is in a meeting with Chief Information Officer (CIO) Owen Evans and several members of his staff. CEO Sherman is inquiring about the availability of information for purposes of tactical and strategic decision making. She needs aggregate information for decisions relative to marketing promotions, service mix, resource allocations, outcome analysis, and payers. Sherman knows the necessary data is collected during daily transactions by different business units at the hospital. A staff member is telling CEO Sherman that compiling the data will be complicated, expensive, and require manual effort each time it is needed.
At that meeting, CEO Sherman has made
CIO Evans and his staff responsible for creating a data warehouse that
will provide decision support at tactical and strategic levels.
THE CASE OF MANADERO'S HOUSE
Jose Manuel Hernández Mogollon
University of Extremadura
CÁCERES (SPAIN)
Abstract
The case centers on the expansion
of a small business in a small village in one of the poorest zones of Europe.
The problem arises from the need to develop these small populated areas,
taking into account the conservation of their natural, artistic and social
backgrounds.
COMPETENCE-ALWAYS APPRECIATED!
Margareta Bernstad
Lund University
LUND, SWEDEN
Abstract
Competence is discussed as a success factor in all sorts of organizations and also in everyday language. Young enthusiastic people graduate from universities and try to get jobs where their knowledge can contribute and where they can develop their competence. Many times they have taken management courses at the university where they learn the need of change from hierarchical to learning organizations.
This case will inspire to discuss
the work situation of young enthusiastic employees from the point of view
of Senge's "The Fifth Discipline" and Kotter's "A force for Change". How
can we use theories on learning organization and leadership in a case like
this where great enthusiasm and motivation in the work force are transformed
into disappointment and disbelief? Is the only solution to quit?
THE CASE OF SPANISH COOPERATIVE SOCIETIES IN THE OLIVE OIL MARKET: BASIS FOR A NEW COMPETITIVE STRATEGY
Alfonso Vargas Sanchez
University of Huelva
HUELVA, SPAIN
Abstract
This case, focused on the olive oil
sector, tries to show how the current internal market situation in Spain,
together with other factors, is leading companies to internationalize their
activity much more and is encouraging co-operatives to undertake concentration
processes in order to increase the added value of their production.
TIAS UNIVERSITY
Linda Ginter Brown
University of Cincinnati
CINCINNATI, OHIO, U.S.A.
Abstract
This case focuses upon a classroom
experience at Tias University in the USA. The course, "Ethics Across the
Curriculum," was designed to help teachers from various backgrounds incorporate
ethics training into their classrooms. Five participants in the class,
all from the same institution, wreaked havoc with the teacher/facilitator's
goals and caused a hostile atmosphere in the class. Only on the last day
was any sense of reconciliation reached between the participants.
TECMAR AND THE INNEO
Guido A. Krickx
California State University, Hayward
HAYWARD, CALIFORNIA, U.S.A.
Abstract
Bruno Claus, CEO of a new company in Belgium, which makes a water-saving device, faced a development delay of one year, which will deplete the capital in 6 months. In summer 1999, Mr. Claus needs to revise his business plan and to attract additional capital.
TAIYO TRADING CO., LTD
Shoichi Hyakkai
Kanagawa University
YOKOHAMA,KANAGAWA, JAPAN
Inichi Sato
Teikyo University
HACHIOJI, TOKYO, JAPAN
Abstract
Section Chief Nitta faced with his subordinate Matsushima's poor performance after listening to the situation from a Sub-Section Chief manager Iwakiri, must analyze the seriousness of situation and make a decision how to react effectively. Making this decision requires an analysis of all aspects of the organizational behavior in Japan. Behind this issue, the reader will need to understand the way of business, and staff development in the company.
MULTIPLE INFORMATION SYSTEMS COPING WITH GROWING AND CHANGING BUSINESS: ROBERT BOSCH CORPORATION (RBUS)
Karl-Heinz Rau
Pforzheim University of Applied
Science
PFORZHEIM, GERMANY
Chetan S. Sankar
Auburn University
AUBURN, ALABAMA, U.S.A.
Abstract
The current non-integrated system
solutions at RBUS had created pockets of implementation gaps between the
business entities leading to complexity and lack of performance measures.
The Chief Information Officer had to establish a strategy to make the multiple
information systems to work together and support changing business needs.
PERFORMANCE BENCHMARKING AT LARALEX HOSPITAL
John Maleyeff
Rensselaer Polytechnic Institute
HARTFORD, CONNECTICUT, U.S.A.
Frank C. Kaminsky
University of Massachusetts
AMHERST, MASSACHUSETTS, U.S.A.
Abstract
An individual is responsible for benchmarking her hospital's performance against similar hospitals. Since quality is not improving, she seeks advice from the quality manager at a manufacturing company. Using statistical techniques commonly used in contemporary quality management, they develop better ways to analyze the hospital's performance to improve quality.
AVON PRODUCTS, INC.:
DEVELOPING A NEW GLOBAL MARKETING STRATEGY
James W. Camerius
Northern Michigan University
MARQUETTE, MICHIGAN, U.S.A.
James W. Clinton
The University of Northern Colorado
GREELEY, COLORADO, U.S.A.
Abstract
Avon Products, Inc., in 1999, was one of the world's largest direct seller of beauty and beauty-related products. >From corporate offices in New York City, Avon marketed product lines to women in 135 countries through 2.8 million independent sales representatives.
In November of 1999, Avon announced
the appointment of Andrea Jung as president and chief executive officer
of the firm. Now in the position of CEO, Ms. Jung felt that she must do
something to rejuvenate Avon's direct-selling model and attract new customers
for what some considered an old fashioned business.
CANBRA FOODS LIMITED
Hal Schroeder and Ross Caffyn
University of Lethbridge
LETHBRIDGE, ALBERTA, CANADA
Abstract
Canbra Foods Limited was a seed processor located in Lethbridge, Alberta, just over 100 kilometers north of the Canada-U.S. border. Canbra produced products like cooking oils, salad oils, margarine, shortening and similar products as well as bulk canola oil by extracting oil from canola seeds. To a lesser extent, it also processed other seeds and was in a joint venture with Control Chemical Corporation in Greenland Corporation which produced environmentally safe vegetable oil-based lubricants for various types of equipment.
The new management team now faced
to challenge of returning Canbra to profitability. Canola oil processing
had been an attractive industry for some year leading up to 1997. Canbra
had been profitable during the mid-1990s and particularly in1996 when net
income exceeded $7.5 million with total assets of $69.8 million. However,
starting in late 1997 and then in 1998 there was a glut in the market and
the price of canola oil declined considerable. In the fiscal year 1997
Canbra's, total sales thus increased only marginally and net income decreased
by about 80 percent to $1.5 million. Fiscal year 1998 saw another small
increase in sales but also an increase in cost of goods sold. With this
squeeze on the margin, Canbra experienced an $80,000 loss in 1998 and needed
a new strategic start to generate profits in the future.
Session 3
TEACHING GLOBAL THINKING AT HOME
Carmen Vega-Carney
Thunderbird (AGSIM)
GLENDALE, ARIZONA, U.S.A.
As part of the WACRA Interactive Case Sessions - a session will be held to discuss issues pertaining to teaching across cultures. There will be panels representing different regions of the world: Western Europe, Central and Eastern Europe, Africa, Asia, and Latin, Central and North America. If you have had expereicne teaching or training in another part of the world, you may want to join. If you think you might be or would like to teach in another part of the world, you may want to meet others who have done so. We promise a lively presentation and discussion.
Panel:
Guiomar Borrás, Thunderbird-AGSIM,
GLENDALE, ARIZONA, U.S.A.
Gerald Crawford, University of North
Alabama, FLORENCE, ALABAMA, U.S.A.
Jose Manual Hernández, University
of Extremadura, CÁCERES, SPAIN
Iona Herseni, Institute for Educational
Sciences, BUCHAREST, ROMANIA
Jane Jackson, The Chinese University
of Hong Kong, HONG KONG, CHINA
Amelia Klein, Wheelock College, BOSTON,
MASSACHUSETTS, U.S.A.
Petr Prochazka, Mendel University,
BRNO, CZECH REPUBLIC
Rao Korukonda, St. Bonaventure University,
ST. BONAVENTURE, NEW YORK, U.S.A.
Session 4
OPENING PLENARY SESSION
"HUNGARY IN PERSPECTIVE"
Session 5
WRITING WITH CASES WORKSHOP
"HOW CASE WRITERS CAN INCREASE THEIR
EFFICIENCY AND EFFECTIVENESS"
James A. Erskine
University of Western Ontario
LONDON, ONTARIO, CANADA
This workshop is dedicated to writing field-based, decision-oriented cases for use in classroom discussions and is of interest to new and experienced case writers using a process that is applicable across all disciplines. The objectives of the writing cases session are to:
1. Introduce the Case Difficulty Cube
concept.
2. Sequence the Normal Steps in Writing
a Case.
3. Introduce the Concept of the Case
Plan Including:
4. Discuss Continuing Challenges
Session 6
DEVELOPING STANDARDS FOR RESEARCH AND TEACHING WITH THE CASE METHOD
Lisa T. Hoshmand
Lesley College
CAMBRIDGE, MASSACHUSETTS, U.S.A.
Abstract
This presentation will be focused
on how we can develop standards for applying the case study method to research
and teaching. The process for developing standards as well as the models
of knowledge on which current practices are based will be considered. It
is proposed that a pragmatic problem-solving model that specifies both
generic standards and utilization-specific standards can help to bring
clarity and integration. It is suggested that such standards can be used
as guidelines for writing case reports and evaluating case studies. Implications
for research and teaching are discussed.
AN ANALYSIS OF SME INTEGRATION VIA RAYTHEON'S VERTICAL PARTNERING PROGRAM
William Naumes
University of New Hampshire
DURHAM, NEW HAMPSHIRE, USA
Michael J. Merenda
University of New Hampshire
DURHAM, NEW HAMPSHIRE, USA
Abstract
This paper presents the results of
a consulting activity by the New Hampshire Industries Group with Raytheon,
Incorporated and some of its suppliers. The study demonstrated the effectiveness
of information sharing between Raytheon and its suppliers as well as the
potential for greater gains through closer ties in the value chain throughout
the entire development process. The study took the form of a combination
of a structured set of case studies and surveys of the prime and secondary
suppliers involved in the program.
SUBJECTIVITY AS A SOURCE OF INSIGHT IN CASE STUDY RESEARCH: A TALE OF THE FIELD
Veronika Kisfalvi
École des Hautes Études
Commerciales de Montréal
MONTREAL, QUÉBEC, CANADA
Abstract
While case study research is an inherently
emotionally subjective method of inquiry, and while this subjectivity can
be a source of bias if it remains unexamined, the researcher's emotions
can
also become a precious source of insight if they are acknowledged and explored.
This paper discusses the role that researcher's subjective emotional reactions
can play in bringing a greater degree of objectivity and a deeper level
of understanding to findings obtained through case study research. The
methodological implications of this subjectivity are also discussed.
Session 7
A CASE HISTORY OF THE UNIVERSITY OF VIRGINIA'S
IN-SERVICE TEACHER EDUCATION MODEL:
EXTENDING WHAT WORKS TO THE FUTURE
Mary P. Abouzeid
University of Virginia
CHARLOTTESVILLE, VIRGINIA, U.S.A.
Abstract
This paper represents a case history
of the teacher education in-service program called McGuffey/TEMPO Reading
Outreach developed and operating at the University of Virginia. The history
will be described in terms of the program needs, technological advances,
and demographic and political environment that effected the development
of the delivery program. A companion CD-Rom will illustrate the video vignettes
and case studies that have remained a constant pedagogical tool through
all phases of program development (including use of VHS, broad band satellite,
production "modules", Asynchronous Transfer Mode [ATM], and the World Wide
Web.)
THE POWER OF QUESTIONS IN
SECOND LANGUAGE CASE DISCUSSIONS
Jane Jackson
The Chinese University of Hong
Kong
HONG KONG SAR, CHINA
Abstract
This paper focuses on the questioning
techniques used by an American case leader in an English-medium management
course in Hong Kong. Using a typology of questions adapted from Christensen
(1991] and Long and Sato [1983], the lecturer's questions and student responses
in the Swatch case discussion were coded and analyzed. After reviewing
the videotape, transcript, and field notes of the discussion, interviews
were held with the case leader and a sampling of students to better understand
the cultural learning situation. This paper offers pedagogical suggestions
for case leaders who seek to promote and sustain student participation
in second language contexts.
ACCOUNTABILITY CASES: LOOKING DEEPER INTO
TESTING FOR TEACHERS
Janice L. Nath
Irma Guadarramma
University of Houston
HOUSTON, TEXAS, U.S.A.
Abstract
The move to teacher accountability
through paper-and-pencil testing is increasing throughout the United States.
This shift may have ramifications that may not have been examined critically--among
those are increasing the likelihood that many minority teachers may be
denied certification (thus increasing the teacher shortage in areas that
can least afford it), allowing unqualified teachers to go into classrooms
while denying skilled ones, having colleges of education closed, changing
the professor/student relationship, and so forth. This paper examines several
cases of preservice teachers and a college of education affected by total
test reliance.
Session 8
SEEWELL CLINIC :
ACCOUNTING FOR INTANGIBLE ASSETS IN PARTNERSHIPS
Sylvain Durocher
Université due Québec
à Hull
HULL, QUÉBEC, CANADA
Jocelyne Gosselin
Université due Québec
à Trois-Rivières
TROIS-RIVIÉRES, QUÉBEC,
CANADA
Abstract
Seewell Clinic is a realistic case
involving two ophthalmologists who decide to form a general partnership.
One partner is an experienced professional, while the other is a young
graduate specializing in laser eye surgery. The scenario describes each
partner's initial proposal and the agreement they finally settle on. As
suggested in the teaching notes, this case may be used in an accounting
theory course to illustrate how to account for the substance of business
proposals in financial statements including solving problems of recognizing
intangible assets, which is a realistic reflection of the work performed
by public accountants.
SOFTWARE QUALITATIVE ANALYSIS AND PRESERVING EXPLORATORY RICHNESS: THE EXPERIENCE FROM TWO CONTRASTING CASES
Suzanne Beaulieu
University of Sherbrooke
SHERBROOKE, QUEBEC, CANADA
Ruth Schmitt
University of Zurich
ZURICH, SWITZERLAND
Abstract
This proposal is to expose two qualitative research projects in the management field that use the case study as a research strategy. These two inductive and grounded-theory-based projects have been conducted independently in two different countries. The chosen cases differ significantly in topic, focus and extent, however, the studies intersect with respect to their methodological approaches. This occurs particularly in the data analysis phase involving the choice of a computer tool. Both authors have questioned the possible loss of richness of their data during the process. Upon completion, they found that research specificity and data richness were both preserved.
The core of this proposal is thus
to detect critical points in the qualitative case study method - especially
in data analysis - which could be enhanced by using software that could
be tailored for specific needs. First, we will explain how the two research
projects emerged, what their objectives were and what methodology was retained
to achieve the fixed goals. Second, we will concentrate on the analytical
part. We will discuss issues pertaining to the different computer tools
available to researchers since computers are increasingly used in qualitative
data analysis today. More particularly, we will focus on the computer software
ATLAS/ti, which was the chosen software tool in the two case studies cited
above, and which appears to be truly helpful for grounded-theory-based
research. Finally, a hands-on demonstration involving the two projects
will be performed to demonstrate the pros and cons of such tools in the
real world.
PARTICIPANTS' CASE WRITING: SUMMARY OF A RECENT EXPERIENCE AND ANALYSIS OF THE RESULTS FOR THE TEACHER AND THE RESEARCHER
Daniel Côté
École des Hautes Études
Commerciales de Montréal
MONTREAL, QUEBEC, CANADA
Abstract
The failure to transfer to better
practices from learning is a serious dilemma that needs to be adressed.
Such a failure requires innovation both in program design as well as in
pedagogical strategies. This paper adresses those questions by presenting
an experimentation conducted at HEC, Montréal where a training program
was developed and delivered for a major financial institution. Also is
presented an analysis of an experiment conducted in a course on learning
organization,offered in this program, where participants were asked to
write a case study about there organization. This experience is analyzed
with respect to its impact on transfers. The results show that this strategy
is helpful to find a solution about this problem.
Session 9
THE USE OF BUSINESS CASES TO OVERCOME
BUSINESS CULTURE STEREOTYPES
Guiomar Borrás
Thunderbird-American Graduate
School of International Management
GLENDALE, ARIZONA, U.S.A.
Abstract
The objective of this presentation
is to guide Business Professors in the usage of business cases to present,
study, investigate, and discover that there is much business culture stereotypes
that can be conquered by presenting new cases to the students. This case
belongs to a series of sustainable business cases published by the World
Resources Institute.
FOURTEEN OPTIONS FOR DESCRIBING INDIVIDUALS IN CASES:
GUIDELINES TO ENHANCE THE WRITING AND PRESENTATION
OF CASES IN WHICH INDIVIDUALS ARE FEATURED
Edward H. Rockey
Pepperdine University-Ventura
County Center
WESTLAKE VILLAGE, CALIFORNIA,
U.S.A.
Abstract
Fully-employed evening students in an Organizational Behavior MBA course write original cases that center on unsolved problems in their workplaces. The descriptions of individuals featured in these cases are of great importance, since both the essence and the resolution of such cases hinge on such aspects
as the communications, actions, skills,
leadership, motivations, influence and values of the key individual(s)
in each case. Student case writers are helped by coaching that guides them
to enrich the descriptions of individuals; this paper delineates fourteen
methods to enhance the descriptions of individuals in cases
STUDENT CASE COMPETITION: KAUFFMAN-ANGELL
CENTER FOR ENTREPRENEURSHIP (KACE)
Bernard Beatty
Wake Forest University
WINSTON-SALEM, NORTH CAROLINA,
U.S.A.
Abstract
When one MBA Program intensified entrepreneurship
activities, it secured funding from organizations that required student
interns to write cases based on their internships. Students participating
competed with each other internally for "best case". The faculty recognized
an opportunity to extend the educational benefits of the case-writing exercise,
and developed an inter-school competition among MBA Programs conducting
similar activities. The competition is expected to add further credibility
to the concept of using cases for education, especially tailored to one
of the most popular MBA specializations today - entrepreneurship.
Session 10
TEACHING AND LEARNING ONLINE:
OPTIONS AND OPPORTUNITIES
Mary Sudzina
The University of Dayton
DAYTON, OHIO, U.S.A.
Abstract
Teaching online requires innovation
in teaching and course design. The question is not whether a course can
be taught online but how a course should be taught online. This
introductory session on teaching and learning online will explore aspects
of successful networked learning techniques. Topics covered include: active
and collaborative learning, network choices for university courses (adjunct,
mixed and online modes), e-mail, computer conferencing, designs for learning
networks, implementation issues, facilitating online courses, and netiquette
and message organizing. Examples from an online course using interdisciplinary
case studies will be offered.
USING WEB-ENHANCED COURSES FOR CASE-BASED INSTRUCTION IN TEACHER EDUCATION: TRIALS AND TRIUMPHS
Lanna Andrews
University of San Francisco
SAN FRANCISCO, CALIFORNIA, U.S.A.
Abstract
The typical home, workplace, and classroom
are no longer bound by four walls. Because telecommunications open up new
possibilities, the University of San Francisco's Special Education and
Teacher Education faculty extends the walls of college classrooms to explore
expanded educational possibilities by using web-based telecommunications
to support courses. Cases are used on the web to develop reflective thinking,
problem solving, and pedagogical content knowing. The advantages and disadvantages
of using cases on the web in teacher education have been determined and
the faculty is preparing for data collection to explore the outcomes.
BRINGING LIFE TO TEACHING/LEARNING OPPORTUNITIES THROUGH EXPERIENTIAL EDUCATION
Eugenia Scott
Butler University
Linda Edington
University of Indianapolis
Pat Boer
Center for Career/Life Planning
INDIANAPOLIS, INDIANA, U.S.A.
Abstract
This presentation will include available
resources from the experiential education literature. Activities designed
for improving teaching strategies which can make learning more meaningful
will be presented. Dr's. Boer, Edington, and Scott will include several
(5) group iniatives and variations of each which can be used in group projects,
organizational skill development, thinking outside the box, pre-planning,
and processing portions of projects in business, medicine, or education.
Handouts will be available with detailed descriptions for each iniative.
Groups will actually attempt as many initiatives and variations as time
permits. For those who have been involved in our 'juggling, rope tricks,
and hacky sack' events, we hope you will enjoy these additions for new
ideas in thinking about the task at hand. Please join us for ways to liven
up the learning.
Session 11
MAKING SIMPLE, BUT EFFECTIVE PRESENTATIONS
Roshan Hubbard
ITT Technical Institute
LOS ANGELES, CALIFORNIA, U.S.A.
Abstract
Because of lack of presentation skills,
many presenters are tempted to rely solely on display technology and other
devices to do the presenting for them, rather than relying on simple, but
effective methods for making effective presentations. Contrary to current
practice, the reliance on the presenter as a medium of information and
the presenter's use of simple techniques can make any presentation an interesting
and memorable
LAW AND JUSTICE IN COMPARATIVE PERSPECTIVE:
SIMULATING THE APPEAL OF OCALAN VS. TURKEY
TO THE EUROPEAN COURT OF HUMAN RIGHTS
James Lennertz
Lafayette College
EASTON, PENNSYLVANIA, U.S.A.
Abstract
During the Spring, 2000 term, I will
be teaching an undergraduate, liberal arts, political science course "Law
and Justice in Comparative Context" and using a semester-long simulation
of Kurdish rebel leader Abdullah Ocalan's appeal to the European Court
of Human Rights of his capture, conviction and death sentence by Turkey.
Students will be assigned to prepare and "play" the roles of attorneys
for either Ocalan or Turkey or as the judges of the ECHR. The interactive
conference presentation will share a systematic analysis and evaluation
of the preparation and operation of the simulation in this course.
SPACESHIP BSB: A UNIQUE EDUCATIONAL LIFE FORM
IN THE GALAXY OF PENN STATE UNIVERSITY
Kathleen M. Murphy
Penn State University at Hazleton
HAZLETON, PENNSYLVANIA, USA
Abstract
Welcome aboard SPACESHIP BSB! Her registered name is the Bachelor of Science of Business (BSB) Baccalaureate Program. She has twelve official docking platforms, which lie, in selected geographic locations within the Commonwealth College (CC) System of Penn State University. These docking platforms include PSU Hazleton.
For the past few years, Penn State University's Main Campus at University Park has been operating at full capacity. Consequently, the faculty and staff at these alternative site locations that were primarily two-year "feeder sites" were encouraged to reorganize and to establish selected baccalaureate programs at their respective locations. By "feeder site" is meant that students fulfill the first two years of a four-year course of study at an alternative Pennsylvania State University campus other than its Main Campus at University Park. In order to preclude the cannibalization of the business programs on the main campus, the BSB program focuses on different business specialties.
This paper examines the journey of
SPACESHIP BSB in its continuing effort to maintain the viability of its
programs while sustaining its educational excellence. As such, the emphasis
of this paper is on off-site campuses and the struggle of these subsystems
to define their place within their particular regional spheres of influence.
This paper invites its readers to dialogue on issues of surviving in the
chaotic world in which we live. Finally, this paper might serve as an interesting
catalyst for business organizations to establish viable executive training
programs beyond the capacity of their home-based locations.
Session 12
LEARNING WITH CASES WORKSHOP
"HOW STUDENTS CAN INCREASE THEIR
EFFICIENCY AND EFFECTIVENESS"
James A. Erskine
University of Western Ontario
LONDON, ONTARIO, CANADA
This workshop is focused on helping students to learn faster and better using cases. The objectives of the learning with cases workshop are to:
PRESERVING THE INDIVIDUAL CASE IN BEHAVIORAL RESEARCH
Mark Kilwein
Clarion University of Pennsylvania
CLARION, PENNSYLVANIA, U.S.A.
Abstract
This paper provides an historical
review and a contemporary analysis of the importance of the individual
case
to behavioral research. Single-case-research designs are reviewed. Meta-analytic
techniques which seek to collapse such bodies of literature, to create
a single group-effect statistic, are reviewed and criticized as a threat
to the scientific integrity of single-case research.
THE COMPEXITY OF MENTORING TO DIVERSITY: A MULTI- CULTURAL
APPROACH TO INNOVATIVE TEACHING BETWEEN
A RESEARCH UNIVERSITY AND A TEACHING UNIVERSITY
Barbara Sjostrom
Yvonne E. G. Rodriguez
Rowan University
CLEMENTON, NEW JERSEY, U.S.A.
Abstract
This paper is based on a case study
which identifies and documents specific strategies utilized in collaborative
mentoring between two universities. One is a public comprehensive research
institution, SUNY, Albany and the other a private, catholic comprehensive
university in Puerto Rico, Universidad del Sagrado Corazon. Two theoretical
frameworks (Rodriguez, 1995; Nieto, 2000) are cross referenced for analyzing
cultural diversity in teaching and mentoring. The data analysis revealed
critical implications for cultural diversity, collaborative mentoring,
curriculum revision and faculty development.
Session 14
SOLVING A SHORTFALL IN EXECUTIVE EDUCATION:
REAL TIME CASE METHOD TEACHING
Robert M. Murphy
United States Army War College
(USAWC)
CARLISLE BARRACKS, PENNSYLVANIA,USA
Abstract
Executive education by its very nature
is designed to prepare the best performers in any organization for positions
of higher responsibility in the organization. The path to higher levels
of responsibility in an organization is usually as diverse as the backgrounds
of the people in the organization. It becomes the challenge to those who
develop executive education programs to take these promising executives
and develop a program that will place them on an even footing in understanding
the complexities of the strategic levels of their respective organization.
In developing these programs, it is also desirable that the diversity of
skills and knowledge that these people usually bring with them are used.
This paper addresses the shortfalls in moving an educationally diverse
group of individuals up the organization and ways to overcome these shortfalls.
CHALLENGES OF DEVELOPING A CASE RESEARCH PROGRAM
IN A SMALLER ARAB COUNTRY
C.P. Rao
Kuwait University
SAFAT, KUWAIT
Abstract
The major purpose of this paper is
to identify and discuss the various challenges faced by a formal program
case research and teaching program in a college of business administration
in a smaller arab country. The experiences and challenges portrayed in
this paper may have relevance to other case research and teaching development
programs in different parts of the world, especially in smaller countries.
The paper identifies the various factors that provided the impetus for
developing a formal case research and teaching program in the college.
The various challenges of case teaching and case research are discussed
separately. The case research program challenges are: undue secrecy on
the part of organizations to provide case related information; problem
of incentives for the faculty to engage in active case research; problems
of academic recognition for case research by the college and university
administration; problem of language translation in gathering case research
information; problem of getting case released by participating organizations
because of their reluctance to expose even minor weaknesses to outside
world; challenges of disguising the identity of organizations in a smaller
country context. Similarly, as a number of case teaching pedagogy related
issues are discussed in the paper. Some of these issues arise because of
faculty orientation to case research and limitations of student orientation
to case method of teaching in a different socio-economic and academic cultural
context.
Session 15
NOVICE CASE WRITERS WORKSHOP
James W. Camerius
N. Michigan University
MARQUETTE, MICHIGAN, U.S.A.
Workshop
New Casewriters Workshop: A panel
of experienced case researchers will discuss how to research, write and
improve cases. Among the topics to be covered will be objectives, various
types of case research, information sources, the writing process, and the
use and development of effective teaching notes. Integral to this process
will be the discussion by panel members of several presented cases and
teaching notes. These cases, still in the development state, will demonstrate
the case editing and improvement process. Experienced case-writers are
also welcome.
Session 16
A NEW PARADIGM IN GROUP CASE ANALYSIS
George Dupuy
Presbyterian College
CLINTON, SOUTH CAROLINA, U.S.A.
Abstract
This will be an informal session where
the presenter will describe the paradigm he has developed for group analysis
and presentation of case studies in class. Session participants will be
encouraged to share their case methodologies so that we can all learn from
each other.
EFFECTIVE TEACHING METHODOLOGIES FOR
TECHNICAL AND BUSINESS EDUCATION
Reginald S. Hubbard
Los Angeles Valley College
LOS ANGELES, CALIFORNIA USA
Abstract
The aim of university education is
to help students learn while they are engaged in courses, and to continue
the learning process throughout their lifetime, but in order to fulfill
this mission, methodologies must be used to make educational experiences
relevant and long-lasting. The best approach for goal is to develop process
skills, by creating student-centered environments in which practical,
hands-on methodologies, such as team tasks, case studies, simulations,
role-plays, and business/education partnerships, are used under the direction
of a teacher who facilitates and manages students' skill development.
Session 17
INCREASING STUDENTS' PARTICIPATION IN RESPONDING
TO CASES THROUGH THE USE OF A LISTSERV AS
AN INSTRUCTIONAL TOOL
Ana Gil
Northeastern Illinois University
Ernestine Riggs
Loyola University Chicago
CHICAGO, ILLINOIS, U.S.A.
Abstract
In this qualitative research, we explore
the use of listserves as instructional instruments at the graduate level,
in a school leadership program, at a midwestern university. An open-ended
5-items questionnaire containing statements that elicited written answers
was constructed, face and content validated. Twenty-five graduate students,
including some who had never used a computer-based technology program before
were administered the questionnaire. In their responses, subjects expressed
their ideas, feelings, opinions, and suggestions about the use of the listserv.
The researchers used the information collected to obtain new insights and
determine the usefulness of such a tool in higher education classrooms.
Respondents input, as well as the available journalistic literature in
the field, agree that listserves are viable classroom instructional tools
that, if used properly, can expand the learning experiences and broaden
the attitudes of all users. This study presents the pros and cons of the
listserv use, as well as anecdotal experiences of students who used this
educational tool for the first time.
The study concludes that listserves,
not only provide mainstream American students' exposure to diverse ways
and forms of written expression, but also help them become aware of new
ways of thinking and processing of ideas from minority cultural and language
groups. Among those are customs, idiomatic expressions, cultures, psyches,
and idiosyncrasies of other students, who may be taking similar classes
simultaneously. Students who use
listserves can get in touch and exchange ideas with others in their own
or other educational institutions across their own cities, states or across
world countries. Students can learn to share ideas about specific topics
or areas of study provided by teachers, that may help them become more
tolerant of opposing points of view. Listserves provide alternatives to
higher education classroom instruction and can prepare students in more
demanding and complex remote computerized learning experiences, i.e. web
courses, in the future
TERM 2 MBA PROGRAM DEVELOPMENT AND
INTERACTIVE SIMULATION
Paula Jordan
National-Louis University
TAMPA, FLORIDA, U.S.A.
Abstract
The College of Management and Business
at National-Louis University has made gigantic accomplishments with course
offerings through the years. The MBA curriculum is one example of this
success. This presentation will discuss the use of a simulation in the
development of three courses in term two of the MBA Program at National-Louis
University. In an effort to link together Managerial Economics, Macroeconomics,
and International Business, an interactive decision-making simulation is
being utilized across all three courses during this term. The use of this
simulation actively engages students in strategic planning, effectively
allocating resources, and coordinating the firm's activities to accomplish
specified goals. This simulation encourages students to apply the economic
concepts from the Managerial Economics course and the Macroeconomics course
to the international business setting. The presentation will conclude with
a demonstration of the simulation model in action.
Session 18
STUDENT TO STUDENT: USING THE CLASSROOM
AS A REAL TIME ORGANIZATION
Carole Parker
St. Michael's College
COLCHESTER, VERMONT, U.S.A.
Abstract
In a small teaching institution, one may find the dilemma of how to teach a course when the enrollment is small. I had such a dilemma and decided to turn it into a challenging experience for both student and instructor.
This presentation will describe the
process involved when two senior business majors enrolled in an elective
course on "Organizational Theory and Design (OT)." Both students had completed
a prerequisite course "Management and Organizational Behavior." Two business
professors teach this course in totally different pedagogical styles. One
instructor is accused by the students of not providing any structure for
the course and turns the responsibility for learning and teaching over
to the students (this class is called XB). The other instructor provides
what can be discerned by the students as a more traditional structure,
although the responsibility for teaching and learning still rests with
the student. One of each student had experienced one of each instructor
in the Management and Organizational Behavior course. Upon enrollment in
Organizational Theory and Design, one student reported wanting to understand
more about how organizations are designed and operate and the other wanted
to have additional theory to apply to her experience in XB.
THE TELECOMMUNICATIONS INDUSTRY IN LATIN
AMERICA: A CASE ANALYSIS
Dana-Nicoleta Lascu
University of Richmond
RICHMOND, VIRGINIA U.S.A.
Abstract
The telecommunications industry is
one of the sectors with the greatest growth potential in Central and Latin
America. Furthermore, most of the countries in the region have not yet
established a communications network that covers 100% of their territory,
and the majority of the countries have recently (within the last ten years)
launched cellular telephony. Most current participants in the telecommunications
industry have invested important resources in order to win a slice of the
market.
The present paper proposes to offer
insights into the telecommunications markets in selected countries in Latin
America and the Caribbean B Brazil, Antigua and Barbuda, Guatemala, Costa
Rica, Honduras, Panama, El Salvador, Nicaragua, Belize, Mexico, and Colombia
B with an emphasis on the wireless industry. In the process, the paper
attempts to offer a segmentation and competitive analysis of the wireless
market in the region.
Session 19
LEARNING WITH CASES WORKSHOP continued
James A. Erskine
University of Western Ontario
LONDON, ONTARIO, CANADA
Session
20
THE INTEGRATION OF TEACHING,
RESEARCH AND SERVICE
THROUGH CASE STUDIES
Mary Ellen Mazey
Wright State University
DAYTON, OHIO, U.S.A.
Abstract
Through the application of the case
study approach, this professor/university administrator has integrated
her teaching, research, and service. Students, especially those at an urban
institution, respond favorably to using the metropolitan environment as
a laboratory and developing their own case studies to implement the course
objectives and the conceptual framework of the course. In addition, many
of these case studies of the studies and professor benefit the community,
governments,and organizations in the region. Therefore, the case study
approach has brought visibility and recognition to the university on a
local, regional, statewide and national scale.
HBS CASE METHOD DEPRIVES
STUDENTS OF AN
AUTHENTIC LEARNING EXPERIENCE
Leon Winer
Pace University
NEW YORK CITY, NEW YORK, U.S.A.
Abstract
Case study teaching patterned on the
Harvard Business School model deprives students of an authentic learning
experience. The teacher is too much of a star and the students are too
passive. As a result, the students fail to develop important skills that
they need for success in their business careers. Four strategies following
the concept of Authentic Learning are suggested. Students
become more active and less dependent on the professor in class, perform
challenging tasks in the real world of business and in general, engage
in projects that are similar to the tasks they are expected to perform
on the job.
Session
21
ENHANCING STUDENT INDIVIDUAL PREPARATION OF A CASE STUDY, USING TOOLS ON THE INTERNET, AN EXAMPLE: MARIBELLE LTD
Benoit Tremblay
École des Hautes Études
Commerciales
MONTREAL, QUEBEC, CANADA
Abstract
Sound individual preparation is the
foundation of learning with cases and is the fundamental prerequisite for
subsequent small and large group learning. Preparing a complex case on
your own is hard work. A large part of the case remain unwritten but is
relevant to the analysis and the solution of the case. An other part of
the case provide an overwhelming amount of information, and your inexperience
with the issue can generate confusion and even frustration. Maribelle Ltd
is that kind of case study. Having to redesign the top-management structure,
the students have to deal with eighty-eight management tasks assigned to
fourteen top-managers. Having a web site allowing students to manipulate
easily the redistribution of those tasks according to different criteria
has revealed itself a good incentive to engage them in a far more adequate
individual preparation and doing so to enhance the process of learning.
ONLINE INSTRUCTION VIA A DYNAMIC ROVING COMMUNITY
Keith Harman
National-Louis University
ST. LOUIS, MISSOURI, U.S.A.
Edward Weiss, Alex Koohang
National-Louis University
CHICAGO, ILLINOIS, U.S.A.
Abstract
E-mail, chat rooms, bulletin boards,
and virtual conference centers are widely used methods to provide online
learning formats. But those methods are limited because instructors and
students are unable to simultaneously explore the Internet and interact
with each other. That limitation can be overcome via IRC (Internet Relay
Chat) software that provides instructors and students the means to create
a DRC (Dynamic Roving Community). This paper discusses basic concepts that
underlie a DRC, how to obtain IRC software, ways to promote the acceptance
and use of a DRC by students, and ideas to enhance its use once it has
been adopted.
Session
22
NOVICE CASE WRITERS WORKSHOP cont.
James W. Camerius
N. Michigan University
MARQUETTE, MICHIGAN, U.S.A.
Session
23
AN APPROXIMATION TO THE
MANAGEMENT
OF INTELLECTUAL ASSETS
IN SPAIN
Carlos Ongallo
University of Extremadura
CÁCERES, SPAIN
Abstract
The measurement techniques in order
to get an accurate vision of the company assets has been recently arrived
in the Spanish companies. The strict rules given by Spanish Accounting
Legislation do not let measure appropriately the patrimony, neither all
posibilities of growing and changing.
APPLICATION OF THE ENTREPRENEURIAL
CREATIVE CASE METHOD
Zlatka Mesko Stok
Tatjana Vosinek Pucer
College of Management
KOPER, SLOVENIA
Abstract
At the Sixteenth International conference WACRA in Caceres, Spain 1999, Professor Janko Kralj has reported about an innovative approach to teaching entrepreneurship and management through entrepreneurial creative cases In essence, teams of students, or a single student, are assigned the task of designing venture ideas for establishing a new, fictitious enterprise. The elaboration is in the form of a business plan and/or the design of a basic enterprise policy (concept, mission, vision, objectives, goals, strategy and structure). This approach has been widened also to include the design of the product that will be produced and sold. The participants assemble a physical prototype of the product from Lego cubs, or shape it in plasticide, provide a technical drawing, make a prospectus, and prepare a calculation of its costs and price that will be later incorporated into the business plan.
The authors of this paper, lecturers
at the College of Management in Koper, Slovenia, are carrying out this
idea in Professor Kralj's courses of Basics of management and
Decision making and managing affairs. They report in this paper about
that application.
Session
24
USING THE INTERNET FOR
DISTANCE WRITING PROJECTS
TO PROMOTE INTERDISCIPLINARY,
MULTI-REGIONAL, AND
CROSS-CULTURAL COMMUNICATION
AMONG STUDENTS
Richard Shrubb
Milwaukee School of Engineering
MILWAUKEE, WISCONSIN, U.S.A.
Abstract
This presentation summarizes an instructional
method that utilizes the Internet to unite students from separate universities
to jointly create formal, written documents. The presentation summarizes
the strengths and weaknesses of the approach that teachers in this activity
actually used and presents recommendations for best gleaning the opportunities
of future distance-writing projects.
MEGA-FUN LEARNING FOR THE Y2K VENUE-II
Victor Selman
The American University
WASHINGTON, DISTRICT OF COLUMBIA,
U.S.A.
Abstract
Learning can be reinforced in many ways. We endorse Dr. Alfred Tomatis' statement that "listening is the road to learning," and are still meditating about his statement that "we read with our ears." But learning without play is difficult---grim and boring presentations may be the major failing of our educational system, and as training for per suasive communication skills. Unorthdox ways currently used in colleges to augment persuasion and articulation ability of business school students is to use stand-up comedy (University of Chicago), song writing, storytelling and improvisation (Vanderbilt University-Owens), and for Shakespearean motivation for other management skills at the corporate executive level (Northrup-Grumman). One novel learning way is by continual repetition through audio-visual media, where information is presented in as risk/stress-free environment as possible. Suggestion, auto-suggestion and suggestology--- have been used, for example, to compress three years of studying French into less than one year by total immersion of students into a close network of parents-teachers-environment-activities where, for example, only French is spoken. See Appendix A, Typical Lesson [French] Using Suggestology.
Another approach is to have abstract
ideas in the sciences translated into physical learning aids, or robotic
device, or toys--where the kernel of the analogies can be retained for
comprehending differing situations, and for future metaphors. See Appendix
B, Selman's MEDICASA Model--for Simulation Devices.
Session
25
MARKETING COST EFFECTIVITY:
A CASE ANALYSIS OF APPROACHES
IN POLAND AND THE UNITED
STATES
Dana-Nicoleta Lascu
University of Richmond
RICHMOND, VIRGINIA, U.S.A.
Abstract
This study examines the relationship between marketing expenses and firm profitability (marketing effectivity) in the United States and Poland. The study's research question is: How do marketing/sales managers in the two countries control the effectivity of marketing expenditures?
Companies frequently do not have an adequate system for gathering, classifying, and analyzing sales and marketing costs and profit data. Too many managers overstress sales volume while neglecting cost controls and profitability analysis. Even when sales managers focus on profits, they look at total profits and do a minimum of analysis by major segments (customers, products, territories, salespeople) if aggregate data are favorable. Thus, many marketing efforts continue to be assigned perfunctorily among territories, product lines or customer classes.
There are problems in the area of
cooperation between marketing, accounting, and other departments of an
enterprise in budgeting and cost control: marketing cost analyses are neglected
due to inadequate communication, lack of power of the marketing department,
and inability to collect and analyze huge volumes of marketing data [Piercy
1986]. This is especially true in Central and Eastern Europe, where marketing
has had traditionally a lower status compared to R&D and engineering.
THE INTERROGATORY CASE STUDY HISTORY LECTURE
Leo Mahoney
Baskent University
ANKARA, TURKEY
Abstract
Pedagogical efforts to overcome deficiencies
of traditional lecture method of teaching history have been variously successful.
However, insufficient attention has been given to superior methodological
advantages of lecturing, and its compatibiliity with psychological conditions
of undergraduate learners, for efficient and imaginative communication
of historical knowledge and interpretation. These educational advantages
to both lecturers and their typically undergraduate audiences may be maximized
when lecturers employ an interrogatory case study approach to textual subject
matter. This paper presents an explanation and an analysis of the aforementioned
thesis and includes a sample interrogatory history lecture case unit.
Session
26
PLENARY SESSION
"COMPLEX DEMANDS ON TEACHING
REQUIRE INNOVATION"
Panel:
Dr. Josef Broder, University of Georgia,
ATHENS, GEORGIA, U.S.A.
Dr. Amelia Klein, Wheelock College,
BOSTON, MASSACHUSETTS, U.S.A.
Dr. Violet Malone, Western Washington
University, BELLINGHAM, WASHINGTON, U.S.A.
Session
27
TEACHING WITH CASES WORKSHOP
"HOW INSTRUCTORS CAN
INCREASE THEIR
EFFICIENCY AND EFFECTIVENESS"
James A. Erskine
University of Western Ontario
LONDON, ONTARIO, CANADA
This workshop is focused on the fundamental pre-requisites necessary for effective teaching and learning with cases. New and experienced teachers alike across all disciplines will have an opportunity to participate in a sample case method class. The objectives to the teaching with cases workshop are to:
1. Review the distinguishing characteristics
of a case and the reasons for using cases.
2. Discuss the fundamental prerequisites
including:
Session 28
THE EVOLUTION OF A TEACHING
CASE:
A RESEARCHER'S PERSPECTIVE
Jane Jackson
The Chinese University of Hong
Kong
HONG KONG S.A.R., CHINA
Abstract
This paper reports on the development
of a research-based teaching case which is designed to help ready expatriates
for positions as NETs (Native English Teachers) in secondary schools in
Hong Kong. By following the construction of the Lone Dog case, which portrays
an Australian NET grappling with a large class of Chinese students, this
paper highlights the merits of a collaborative, research process in case
development. Decision-forcing cases that deal with the complex demands
of real classroom events can help ensure that issues of relevance to teachers
are addressed in orientation or professional development programs.
DISRUPTION, DISCOVERY AND OPPORTUNITY
Robert Swinth
Montana State University
BOZEMAN, MONTANA, U.S.A.
Abstract
The purpose of this paper is twofold:
1) A strategic opportunity is emerging in regards to disruptive technologies.
With new conceptual tools and framework for thinking about innovation,
we hope to show how one can better understand current forces changing the
dynamics in many industries. 2) This perspective lends itself to the case
analysis technique for predicting performance. We hope to assess this use
of the case methodology.
CASE BASED METHODOLOGIES
WITHIN THE FRAMEWORK
OF MARKETING RESEARCH
COMPARATIVE ANALYSIS
Valeriy Smaznoy
Nikolay Drozd
Donetsk State University of Economy
& Trade
DONETSK, UKRAINE
Abstract
INFORMATION UNAVAILABLE AT PRESS TIME
Session
29
INNOVATION IN TEACHING TEACHERS: CASE STUDIES AND THE USE OF CASE STUDIES IN PROFESSIONAL DEVELOPMENT
David Bullock
Emily De La Cruz
Samuel Henry
Portland State University
PORTLAND, OREGON, U S A
Abstract
Teacher educators are being challenged
to prepare technology literate teachers. Before university faculty can
undertake this task they must be technologically literate themselves. Supporting
the conference theme, "Complex Demands on Teaching Require Innovation,"
this paper details three case studies which describe innovative approaches
to incorporating technology into the teacher education curriculum: I) highlights
of a mentor-mentee relationship that served as the catalyst for a school-wide
faculty mentoring program; II) the use of film cases to make visible the
complexities of teaching; and III) the use of electronic portfolios as
a way of assessing students' understanding of diverse education contexts.
Session
30
POWER FRAGMENTATION AND STRUCTURAL INERTIA: THE UNIVERSITY OF SEVILLE IN SEARCH OF CHANGE
Emilio P. Díez de Castro
Juan A. Tamayo Gallego
University of Seville
SEVILLE, SPAIN
Abstract
This paper describes a case about
the transformations taking place at the University of Seville from an organization
standpoint. The University, with more than 85.000 students, is immersed
in an innovation process in order to achieve higher competence levels.
Experience associated to quality management provides a privileged framework
for the analysis of strengths and inertia affecting change. We reflect
on the development and exhaustion of the model and on two challenging and
polemic approaches: the contract-program and quality accreditation. Finally,
we also point out the actions designed by the Vice-rectorate of Quality
contributing to the implementation of a change strategy.
SISTER ANNETTE BELLAVANCE - HER TWO PASSIONS
Joelle Piffault
École des Hautes Études
Commerciales
MONTREAL, QUEBEC, CANADA
Abstract
This case describes the turnaround that Sister Annette Bellavance, from the Congregation of the Sisters of Notre Dame, has been operating since she was appointed principal of Collège Regina Assumpta in 1971.
To understand the turnaround and the restructuring, the authors describe briefly the history of the College since its opening in 1889 in the heart of Montreal. They also provide some background information about catholic private education and the growing presence of a modern bureaucracy in Quebec's life. In 1971, Sister Annette inherits an institution in dire financial shape. Will she be forced to close the College? To her astonishment she finds that parents are ready to fight to keep their College opened. Sister Annette will then lead the College to recovery and transform it in a vibrant institution.
The authors describe the education she and her siblings received from their parents. A tightly knit-catholic family where education, learning, good behaviour, and management are the foundations of a meaningful life. The authors also describe the step by step restructuring of the College and the implementation of a strategy of financial self-sufficiency. To deal with the new educational environment, Sister Annette and her board will take some important decisions and create new services.
Strategy is more than a concept for Sister Annette, who volunteers some insight on what it takes to be a good manager; communication and power-sharing are the ingredients for a well run school. Listening to students and stimulating their imagination are the ingredients to be a good teacher.
To conclude the case, Sister Annette
explains her vision for the next five years; in our new world of technologies,
she believes a good project does not last more than five years that is
why she is creating a new interactive center.
THE EVENT AS A CASE STUDY:
THE ATLANTA OLYMPICS AND
ITS IMPACT ON SYDNEY
2000 ORGANIZATIONAL STRATEGIES
Janek Ratnatunga
Monash University
CAULFIELD JUNCTION, VICTORIA,
AUSTRALIA
Abstract
This paper presents a an overview of the lessons learned by successful and unsuccessful small businesses during the 1996 Summer Olympic games in Atlanta, Georgia and considers their impact organisations involved in the 2000 Summer Olympic games in Sydney, Australia.
There were two major reasons for undertaking Olympic events analyses. The first is to undertake a longitudinal study of factors critical to businesses specifically catering to the significant increase in perceived demand for goods and services that arise when staging an Olympics. The second major purpose of undertaking Olympic events analyses is to apply the lessons learned from the longitudinal study as a guide for businesses gearing up for a future Olympiad, or similar large-scale special events.
Businesses expecting to make a quick fortune out of the Sydney Olympics are likely to be disappointed, as the experiences of entrepreneurs in Atlanta indicate that it would not be an easy task. The study found that the businesses most likely to be successful are ones that are already established with surplus funds to deploy into new ventures in which they can afford to take risks.
The Olympics in Australia is less
than a year away, and it appears that whilst the organisers have learnt
and benefited from the painful lessons of Atlanta, there are many very
concerning areas up to this stage of event organization.
Session
31
INTEGRATION OF MULTIDISCIPLINARY
KNOWLEDGE IN CASE
BASED TEACHING OF GLOBAL
MARKETING
A. Reza Hoshmand
Lesley College
CAMBRIDGE, MASSACHUSETTS, U.S.A.
Abstract
This paper describes the use of case
based teaching in integrating multidisciplinary perspectives in global
marketing. The proposed approach is in response to two growing concerns
in American business and management education, namely, insufficient exposure
of students to the challenges of doing business in markets other than one's
own, and the limited relevance of management models that are removed from
the realities of practice. Examples from teaching in the area of global
marketing are presented. The broader implications of this approach for
business and management education will be discussed.
TEACHING A CASE STUDY
COURSE IN ONE WEEK:
INNOVATION, DETERMINATION,
AND PERSPIRATION
Stephen P. Hundley
Patricia L. Fox
Indiana University-Purdue University
Indianapolis
INDIANAPOLIS, INDIANA, U.S.A.
Abstract
At most higher education institutions in the United States, student retention, motivation, and persistence issues are of paramount concern to faculty, administrators, and policymakers. Clearly, most campuses operate with an outdated, agrarian-based academic calendar, one that often impedes, rather than facilitates, persistence to degree completion in a timely manner. In order to address student needs and institutional priorities, a shift in the way classes are taught needs to occur.
The Department of Organizational Leadership
and Supervision at Indiana University-Purdue University Indianapolis (IUPUI)
offers several case-based courses in one-week intensive formats. Given
the type of learner we serve, the nature of the courses we teach, and the
type of learning outcomes expected, teaching a case study course in a concentrated
format requires innovation, determination, and perspiration from faculty,
students, and administrators.
LEARNING THROUGH QUESTIONING:
SOCRATIC APPROACH
TO FOSTER MULTIPLE INTELLIGENCES
Abdul Latif
Grand Valley State University
ALLENDALE, MICHIGAN, U.S.A.
Abstract
Plato's Dialogues are analyzed to
generate different forms of questions. The practice of the questioning
in an interactive setting is known as the Socratic method. In reference
the Socratic method, Gardner's theory multiple intelligences are also analyzed.
Generating and exploring different forms of questions help teachers overcome
typical methods of teaching. Teachers will be able to motivate students
by using the specific strategies Socrates himself used with his disciples.
In order to make learning by questioning graphically pleasing, Socratic
questions are linked to art works of da Vinci, Rembrandt, Goya, and Picasso
who went beneath the surface to capture the deeper aspects of subject matter.
Session 32
TEACHING AND LEARNING ON-LINE: LESSONS LEARNED
Angela Durante
Lewis University
ROMEOVILLE,ILLINOIS, U.S.A.
Alex Koohang
National-Louis University
NOWY SACZ, POLAND
Edward Weiss
National-Louis University
CHICAGO, ILLINOIS, U.S.A.
Abstract
The enhancement of on-line education
depends largely upon experiences and lessons we learn. This paper considers
the on-line education efforts of three institutions and the lessons learned
from their start-up experiences. The lessons learned reported in this paper
could enhance and strengthen the on-line teaching and learning. The lessons
should help those who are involved or would like to get involved in on-line
education in any capacity
KEYNOTE SYSTEMS INC: STRATEGIC
CHOICES FOR
AN INTERNET INFASTRUCTURE
COMPANY
Jeff Ellis
Babson College
BABSON PARK, MASSACHUSETTS, U.S.A.
Abstract
The objectives of this presentation
will be: (1) to immerse attendees in the excitement and seriousness of
Internet commerce through a dynamic company engaged at the center of the
evolution of the industry; (2) to introduce participants to an effective,
interdisciplinary case study that is available for instructors to adopt
for their own classes; (3) to report on class room tests of the case, to
recommend a choice of teaching approaches for using the case, and to hand
out a teaching note for potential adopters to consult; and (4) to engage
participants in a discussion of the challenges faced by the management
of the company and to consider suggestions for exploiting those challenges.
INTERACTIVE MULTIMEDIA SIMULATIONS IN MANAGEMENT EDUCATION: PRESENT STATUS AND FUTURE DEVELOPMENTS
Lawrence M. Lamont
Washington and Lee University
LEXINGTON, VIRGINIA, U.S.A.
Abstract
Interactive simulations using multimedia
technology continue to be popular as a way of delivering management education.
The paper explores the reasons for the continuing interest and discusses
their present status as teaching and learning tools. A scenario for the
future of management education is proposed and new developments in interactive
multimedia simulations are examined in this context. The paper concludes
that multimedia simulations will become a significant part of the campus
and distance learning environment.
Session
33
DEVELOPING GENDER-BASED CASES FOR THE GLOBAL CLASSROOM
Anne Schroer-Lamont
Washington and Lee University
LEXINGTON, VIRGINIA, U.S.A.
Abstract
Worldwide, people are entering the
workplace unprepared to make appropriate professional and personal decisions
related to gender. Diversity in the workplace will continue to be a major
theme in the 21st century, with the influx of women continuing
to rise in management, higher education administration and teaching, industry,
communications, law and medicine. Men and women at all levels of employment
must be taught how to appropriately manage the issues of gender which naturally
arise within work teams and throughout the hierarchy of the employment
setting. This paper identifies universal gender topics and provides suggestions
for weaving these issues into the writing of cases for the global classroom.
TOTAL QUALITY MANAGEMENT
IN EDUCATION
A HOLISTIC APPROACH
Willem DeBeer
Technikon Pretoria
PRETORIA, SOUTH AFRICA
Abstract
For a country to compete in the global village, its education system should deliver educated people o fthe desired quality. in the desired quality equation parameters such as productivity, wealth creation and customer satisfaction appear. To account for quality with respect to these parameters a holistic approach to total quality management (TQM) is needed. Quality assurance components are the responsibility for:
ECONOMIC DEVELOPMENT AND PRIVATIZATION IN TURKEY: AN ANALYSIS OF THE GUCBIRLLIGI HOLDING (GBH) MODEL
Gerald Crawford
University of North Alabama
FLORENCE, ALABAMA, U.S.A.
Abstract
The objectives of this paper are to:
(1) show the major role that Turkey is playing in economic development
and political stability in a potentially volatile Middle East; (2) document
the success of the slow but steady privatization process currently underway
in Turkey; and (3) examine the apparent success of a creative form of business
organization that is leading to greater privatization in the Aegean Region
of Turkey, the Gucbirligi Holding Model.
Session
34
PLENARY SESSION
"DISTANCE LEARNING: FAD,
FASHION, FABLE OR FUTURE"
Panel:
Dr. Lars Bengtsson, Lund University,
LUND, SWEDEN
Dr. James Erskine, The University
of Western Ontario, LONDON, ONTARIO, CANADA
Dr. Ronald Patten, DePaul University,
CHICAGO, ILLINOIS U.S.A.
Dr. Marlene Rosenkoetter, University
of North Carolina, WILMINGTON, NORTH CAROLINA, U.S.A.
Dr. Mary Sudzina, The University
of Dayton, DAYTON, OHIO, U.S.A.
Session
35
PLENARY SESSION continued
"DISTANCE LEARNING: FAD,
FASHION, FABLE OR FUTURE"
Session
36
FACILITATING CLASSROOM
DISCUSSIONS WORKSHOP
"WHAT TO DO IF IT HAPPENS
TO YOU"
James A. Erskine
University of Western Ontario
LONDON, ONTARIO, CANADA
Workshop
This workshop is focused on managing
the case classroom discussion process. An opportunity is provided for both
new and experienced teachers and across all disciplines to discuss a variety
of situations which may occur in discussion based learning using cases
and a range of possible options.
Session
37
INNOVATIVE RESOURCES AND
STRATEGIES FOR
APPLYING CASES TO TEACHER
EDUCATION
Mary R. Sudzina
The University of Dayton
DAYTON, OHIO, U.S.A.
Abstract
This interactive book session will
highlight the work of 15 teacher educators featured in Sudzina's Case
Study Applications for Teacher Education: Cases of Teaching and Learning
in the Content Areas [Allyn & Bacon, 1999a]. Cases are drawn from
case texts, professor and teacher-written narratives, short stories and
novels, videos, "live cases," stories in the news, cases on the World Wide
Web, and from students' own dilemmas in field placements and student teaching.
Strategies and resources shared will be both generic and specific. Content
areas addressed include: early childhood, educational psychology, elementary
language arts, secondary English, multicultural education, special education,
ethics, computer applications, and school administration.
NEGLECTED VOICES: WHAT
CASE METHOD RESEARCH CAN TELL
US ABOUT THE STAKEHOLDERS
IN EDUCATION
Sandra Josephs Hoffman
Donna Hooker Topping
MILLERSVILLE UNIVERSITY
MILLERSVILLE, PENNSYLVANIA, U.S.A.
Abstract
This paper presents background on
the voices of stakeholders in education, and a meta-analysis of seventy
teacher-research studies conducted over seven years. Specifically, it addresses
two voices in education that traditionally have been neglected - classroom
teachers and their students. Five patterns of student responses are presented,
and implications are discussed.
Session
38
PECULIARITIES OF BUSINESS-LIKE
GAMES ELABORATIONS
IN THE HIGHER MATHEMATICS
COURSE IN THE
HIGHER TECHNICAL SCHOOLS
Vera Petruk
Technical University of Vinnitsa
VINNITSA, UKRAINE
Abstract
During the 10 year period we investigated
how to use games in the teaching of technical university students to higher
mathematics. Business-like games elaborations in the special subject of
higher mathematics is a new concept. There are many theoretical and practical
problems in it. Some of them we offer to you.
COMPLEX DEMANDS ON ELECTRONIC
TEACHING RESOURCES:
INNOVATION AND RESTRUCTURING
BY CASE METHOD
Mark Charles Fissel
Augusta State University
AUGUSTA, GEORGIA, U.S.A.
Abstract
Teachers have increasingly placed
greater demands upon their institutions for 1) classroom technologies,
2) computing infrastructure, and 3) technology training. Simultaneously,
institutions have had to invest increasingly more resources into hardware
and software as systems have become more complex. For example, computing
services have had to supply more personal computers and greater quantities
of software packages (including licensing and virus-protection costs);
media centers have had to develop a broader menu of classroom services
(i.e. smart boards as well as the old analog technologies); libraries must
shelve CDs and electronic data as well as printed works, and must adjust
their budgets accordingly. How can we train educational administrators
to deal with these complex demands on electronic resources as they exist
in diverse institutional settings?
Session
39
DISTANCE EDUCATION: ON-LINE COURSES IN BUSINESS SCHOOLS
Peter Olson
Rensselaer Polytechnic Institute
HARTFORD, CONNECTICUT, U.S.A.
Abstract
Distance education has been with us
for a long time, over 150 years, however with the advent of the Internet;
we are seeing a renewed growth of distance education in higher education.
Many educators and researchers have defined distance education over the
years (Holmberg, 1986; Keegan, 1986; Verdiun and Clark, 1991), many define
distance education when the instructor and the student are separated by
distance a medium or media of communications are employed and an educational
institution. This definition may be appropriate as a beginning, however
for this study, I would like to further refine the definition of distance
education in terms of the communication media, the Internet. Therefore,
distance education will be defined as the student who is separated from
the instructor by distance and all communication is done through the Internet.
The literature, though relatively modest, has reported on this new media
in higher education. What are the reasons why a university would begin
an Internet course on their campus? What are the advantages of doing this
and how will it affect the students, the faculty members and the administrators?
THE DEVELOPMENT PROCESS OF AN ASSESSMENT INSTRUMENT FOR THE SUPERVISION OF TEACHER EDUCATION INTERNS
Tuula Heide
University of Idaho
MOSCOW, IDAHO, U.S.A.
Abstract
It is apparent at a Research II Institution in the Northwest that there is a need for a new assessment tool that would accurately and reliably evaluate interns' performance. The purpose of this study was to develop an appropriate instrument for mentor teachers and university supervisors to consistently and accurately evaluate teacher education interns' performance based on the INTASC standards and the standards adopted by the state.
The presentation will discuss rationale,
results, and implications for teacher education programs regarding interns'
supervision and assessment. Also the perceptions of supervisors, mentor
teachers, and interns will be reflected through the presentation.
HOW TO TRAIN SUPERVISORS TO USE A NEWLY DEVELOPED ASSESSMENT INSTRUMENT TO SUPERVISE TEACHER EDUCATION INTERNS
Tuula Heide
University of Idaho
MOSCOW, IDAHO, U.S.A.
Abstract
A new assessment tool was developed to evaluate teacher education interns' performance based on the INTASC standards and the standards adopted by the state at a Research II institution in the Northwest. A need for training was determined based on the feedback from College of Education faculty, mentor teachers, university supervisors, and Education students.
This study will describe the format
and the content of the training materials, the format of the training session(s),
and the actual procedure within the sessions(s). Also the development of
the training materials will be discussed, and the highlights of the training
will be shared.
Session 40
MBA COURSE PRACTICUM: A ONE COMPANY INTEGRATED
CASE STUDY DRIVEN LEARNING EXPERIENCE
Jeff Ellis
Babson College
BABSON PARK, MASSACHUSETTS, U.S.A.
Abstract
The Objectives of this presentation
will be: (1) to share the experience of a teaching innovation that used
ten case studies all written on one company that were first taught and
then extended in to student consulting partnership projects with executives
from within the company; (2) to describe the use of cases and projects
in sample designs and experimental designs that highlighted similarities
and differences across the corporation and also focused student teams on
comparisons of their work; (3) to discuss a complex of questions regarding
the special value or otherwise of innovations mixing case study teaching
with projects and field studies; and (4) to stimulate a discussion on the
practical questions of organizing such innovations within universities
and of the administrative and reward implications of such work. My personal
experiences might help to make this a highly charged debate.
FINANCIAL STATEMENTS: KEY TO EFFECTIVE TEACHING USING THE CASE METHOD AND COMPUTER-BASED SIMULATION
Kamal M. Abouzeid
Lynchburg College
LYNCHBURG, VIRGINIA, U.S.A.
Abstract
Incorporating financial analysis into
the case and simulation methods helps in the development of analytical
framework for strategy formulation and implementation; for problem-solving
and decision-making; and most importantly,for effective teaching using
the two pedagogical methods.
Session 41
DO WEB-BASED PROJECTS IMPROVE STUDENT LEARNING?
Douglas N. Ross
TOWSON UNIVERSITY
TOWSON, MARYLAND, U.S.A.
Abstract
This paper reports on experiences
of upper level undergraduate students with the use of web-enhanced instruction
(WEI) involving two different course design tools--WebCT and CourseInfo--
to respond to case project assignments. While arguments for increased use
of WEI are compelling, the paper notes that nearly 80% of students surveyed
agreed that "the team preferred a more traditional means of communicating".
This suggests a breech between the opportunities of a $600 billion post-secondary
education market and the threat posed by traditional student preferences.
How to cross the chasm from early adopter market to majority market in
a manner that enhances student learning is the challenge.
LEARNING THE CULTURE OF FRANCE THROUGH VIDEO
Anthony Sallustio
Pace University
NEW YORK, NEW YORK, U.S.A.
Abstract
This is a project of considerable
scope that will devise a program to learn French culture and language at
the intermediate and advanced levels through a combined use of video, computer-assisted
instruction and the Internet. The presentation will center on three course
designs. Two of the models will combine language exercises with the cultural
content at the intermediate and advanced levels. The third design will
not require French language skills as a pre-requisite and will address
students who wish to study the culture of France in English. The content
of the video will focus on the rich history and contributions of Provence
in the south of France.
Session 42
CASE STUDY IN TEACHING
THE LANGUAGE OF FIRST-ORDER LOGIC
Yuanqian Chen
Central Connecticut State University
NEW BRITAIN, CONNECTICUT, U.S.A.
Abstract
The language of first-order logic
(FOL) is used extensively in mathematics, computer science, philosophy,
and other symbolic sciences. Its precision and lack of ambiguity are essential
to the study of reasoning and rationality. This paper discusses two cases
that are used in a symbolic logic classroom to demonstrate the difference
between the language of first-order logic and English as well as the power
of the language of first-order logic in deduction and in analysis of inconsistent
theories. The first case is about the debate among mathematicians over
the current calculus reform. The second case discusses a mistake made by
a famous mathematician in history and the development of a new branch of
mathematics from the effort of fixing the problem.
CASES FROM THE THEORY OF INVERSE
PROBLEMS IN MATHEMATICS
George Pelekanos
Southern Illinois University
EDWARDSVILLE, ILLINOIS, U.S.A.
Georgia Pyrros
University of Delaware
NEWARK, DELAWARE, U.S.A.
Abstract
Most math professors focus their presentations on abstractions. It is true, some students are fascinated by abstract intellectual games but the majority of them want to know what you do with all those equations. They want to taste the excitement of real life problems that are being solved by mathematicians. It is the professor's responsibility to make the abstractions relevant to real life experiences and to show their class the achievements that are accomplished every day.
The theory of inverse problems is
a fascinating area of math and a lot of students could be attracted to
this field if they could only see some of the exciting problems that can
be solved
Session 43
CLOSING SESSION
Panel:
Dr. Lars Bengtsson, Lund University,
LUND, SWEDEN
Dr. Joelle Piffault, École
des Hautes Études Commerciales, MOUNT ROYAL, QUEBEC, CANADA
Dr. Ramon Ariel Quesada, J.A. Echeverria
Technical University, HABANA, CUBA
Dr. Robert Van Haarlem, Wageningen
Agricultural University, WAGENINGEN, NETHERLANDS
Dr. C.P. Rao, Kuwait University,
SAFAT, KUWAIT